“Have you read there's a recent book Stalin's War by Sean McMeekin that came out a lovely history you know kind of a revisionist history or someone but impeccably academic…”
Why: He describes it as a lovely history and impeccably academic.
“autobiography by Jahangir called the Tozuki Jahangiri, and is generally believed not quite to be the equal of his great grandfather's diary, which really is one of the great memoirs of all time. But it's an extraordinary account of an extraordinary man.”
Why: Though considered slightly below the Baburnama, it is an extraordinary account that defies stereotypes about Jahangir.
Books a speaker argued against in episodes published this week.
“But the guy who's written the main account we have of Akbar's inner circle, which is called the Ayni Akbari, and he just thinks quite literally that the sun shines out of Akbar, all parts of Akbar, and he lays it on with a trowel.”
Why: While it is the main account of Akbar's inner circle, the author is heavily biased in flattering Akbar and hostile toward Salim.