“And what Solzhenitsyn does, he never, in the novella Ivan Denisovich or in this novel, In the First Circle, he never screams out his pain or the pain of his prisoners or his observation.”
In the First Circle on EconTalk
Recommends
Books they recommend that someone else wrote.
“And what Solzhenitsyn does, he never, in the novella Ivan Denisovich or in this novel, In the First Circle, he never screams out his pain or the pain of his prisoners or his observation.”
Why: Masterful artistic understatement that conveys the psychological and moral reality of the prison camps without melodrama.
“And when I use these two adjectives, I'm not really trying to address One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich in the way that many of us in the West received and perceived the novella.”
Why: Beyond exposing the excesses of Stalin's camps, it demonstrates artistic mastery unseen in Russian literature since the early twentieth century.
“One thing I would add, I don't know of any work that is more rewarding to read than this one. This is a masterpiece akin to Dostoevsky, Tolstoy, Pasternak, Bulgakov. this is some of the best writing of Russian literature, period.”
Why: It is one of the most rewarding works in Russian literature, with deep and complex characters, themes, and plot action that interact masterfully.
“I would say that's the main fault of the first circle, deleting those nine chapters from the original version that Sosha Nitsan had completed. The first circle didn't hold together nearly as well or as successfully as in the first circle does.”
Why: Deleting nine chapters from the original manuscript caused the expurgated version not to hold together as well as the restored version.
“I think if we go back to One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, those of your listeners who have read that novel already or who may want to in the future, Your listeners are, and you and I, are absolutely astounded by the horror of this one day…”
Why: Astounding and understated portrayal of the horror of a single 24-hour period in a Soviet labor camp.
“And this is a moment that goes back, this particular moment that we're referring to, goes back to Tolstoy's novel War and Peace, when one of the main characters turns yet again to a peasant.”
“And so Sozhenitsyn has to submit his One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich to a literary journal, Nový Mir, The New World, that he feels he has the best chance to get it published.”
Why: It is an honest, exciting work of literary genius and artistic mastery that electrified Soviet readers.
“And Solzhenitsyn's history of this period of the camps, he called the gulag archipelago because he saw it as a chain of islands that were linked together. Across the entire country.”
“But his follow-up to The Oak and the Calf, that's the name of it in English translation, the follow-up to Oak and the Calf is going to be translated now, or has been translated and will appear only in November of 2018.”
“We have a period where the writings of Solzhenitsyn, like in the First Circle or Cancer Ward or the Gulag or August 1914, are just not going to be tolerated…”
“A number of the works of Dostoevsky, for example, his notes from the underground, were never printed in the Soviet period and were forbidden from being written.”
“The second book that Sozhenitsyn takes, of course, is a copy of the Bible And the third book is a copy of Vladimir Dahl's collection of Russian proverbs…”
“The second book that Sozhenitsyn takes, of course, is a copy of the Bible And the third book is a copy of Vladimir Dahl's collection of Russian proverbs…”