PodCited
BooksTop 100WeeklyTopicsPeoplePodcasts

Book links are affiliate links (Amazon, Bookshop.org). As an Amazon Associate PodCited earns from qualifying purchases. Quotes come from machine transcripts of each episode's audio or captions.

AboutHow it worksCollectionsPrivacyhello@podcited.com

← The Rest Is History

Books mentioned in

Custer vs. Crazy Horse: Horse-Lords of the Plains (Part 3)

The Rest Is History

2024-05-08 · 49 min · 2 books recommended · 2 critiqued

The reading list

  1. Cover of Earth Is All That Lasts
    Earth Is All That Lasts

    Mark Lee Gardner

    ⚡ critiqued at 00:08:10

  2. Cover of The Earth Is Weeping
    The Earth Is Weeping

    Peter Cozzens

    👍 recommended at 00:18:40

  3. Cover of The Sioux
    The Sioux

    Guy E. Gibbon

    👍 recommended at 00:20:10

  4. Cover of My Life on the Plains
    My Life on the Plains

    George Armstrong Custer

    ⚡ critiqued at 00:22:40

Start here

“Peter Cousins does this brilliantly in his book, The Earth Lies Weeping. He says, The grand iron in the Great Plains is that none of the tribes with which the army would clash were native to the lands they claimed.”

The Earth Is Weeping on The Rest Is History

Recommended in this episode

Books a speaker recommends that someone else wrote.

“Peter Cousins does this brilliantly in his book, The Earth Lies Weeping. He says, The grand iron in the Great Plains is that none of the tribes with which the army would clash were native to the lands they claimed.”

Why: Praised for brilliantly demonstrating that the Plains tribes who fought the U.S. Army were themselves recent migrants and conquerors rather than timeless inhabitants of those lands.

The Earth Is Weeping by Peter Cozzens
Dominic Sandbrook, Host

“So Guy Gibbon, who wrote a brilliant history of the Sioux, for most people in the world, the very symbol of Indianness is the Sioux eagle feather headdress.”

Why: Recommended as a brilliant history of the Sioux.

The Sioux by Guy E. Gibbon
Dominic Sandbrook, Host

⚡ Critiqued in this episode

Speakers who argue against the book or name its limits.

“you know, the earth is all that lasts, the earth lies weeping, all that kind of. The vast majority of them are by white American university academics who are often putting on a sort of cod Native American voice…”

Why: Critiqued as part of a trend of books by white American writers affecting an artificial Native American voice and poeticized framing.

Earth Is All That Lasts by Mark Lee Gardner
Dominic Sandbrook, Host

“In the beginning of My Life on the Plains, he has this kind of mad riff where he talks about how the native peoples of America are clearly Israelites.”

Why: Tom characterizes Custer's opening argument that Native Americans were Israelites as a mad riff.

My Life on the Plains by George Armstrong Custer
Tom Holland, Host

Passing References

Named without an opinion attached.

“there was the Lady Bird book. The Lady Bird book of Custer. Custer's Last Stand. And those books freely use the term, which a lot of people now find very offensive, Red Indian…”

Custer's Last Stand by Quentin James Reynolds
Dominic Sandbrook, Host

“no matter the, you know, Dee Brown, Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee and all the attempts to see how the West was won as being how the West was lost…”

Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee by Dee Alexander Brown
Tom Holland, Host

“Did you read Harry Potter to your children? You probably didn't, did you? No. They have a thing called a Patronus, which is like a spirit animal.”

Harry Potter (Series) 1-7 by J. K. Rowling
Dominic Sandbrook, Host

“Oh, as in like Philip Pullman? Kind of, a bit like that. Yeah, a little bit like that. So there's an element of that with these chaps.”

His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman
Tom Holland, Host

Start here

“Peter Cousins does this brilliantly in his book, The Earth Lies Weeping. He says, The grand iron in the Great Plains is that none of the tribes with which the army would clash were native to the lands they claimed.”

The Earth Is Weeping on The Rest Is History

Or press play on any quote to hear it in the original conversation.