“So here's a book. It's called Land, Politics, and Nationalism, A Study of the Irish Land Question by Philip Bull. So he goes through Irish land debates in the 19th century.”
Land, Politics and Nationalism on EconTalk
Recommended in this episode
Books a speaker recommends that someone else wrote.
“So here's a book. It's called Land, Politics, and Nationalism, A Study of the Irish Land Question by Philip Bull. So he goes through Irish land debates in the 19th century.”
Why: It is a good book on 19th-century Irish land debates that gains even more meaning when read in a cluster alongside other books on the subject.
“Those you want to reread after many years. So Tocqueville, Plato's Republic, Adam Smith, the very best books. As you are older and no more, they become very different.”
Why: It is one of the books with the most wisdom and becomes much better and richer when reread as you get older.
“I'm doing that same thing with a book called, one of my books I'm reading right now is On Human Nature by Roger Scruton. It's a set of lectures he gave.”
Why: Although complicated at first, on the third attempt Roberts really liked it and finally saw what Scruton was trying to accomplish.
“I remember reading, I read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance by Robert Persig when I was a lot younger, you know, 40, 50 years ago, and I loved it.”
Why: He loved it when he was younger and still liked it upon rereading.
“The very best works I will reread a few times. So something like Moby Dick or Flaubert or War and Peace, absolutely. I'll read them three, four times.”
Why: It is one of the very best novels ever written and worth rereading multiple times across one's life.
“It's mostly about man's quest for God, I think. Yeah. And Melville doing a kind of ideological tour of the theological universe, and that is sandwiched in between a story about chasing a white whale.”
Why: It is one of the very best novels, offering an ideological tour of the theological universe, law, science, abolitionism, and obsessive human quests.
“let's say proust holstoy's war in peace cervantes moby dick and dickens bleak house gosh that's oricoliver's travels that would be the off the top of my head list.”
Why: Included among the top five novels everyone should read.
“let's say proust holstoy's war in peace cervantes moby dick and dickens bleak house gosh that's oricoliver's travels that would be the off the top of my head list.”
Why: Included as a contender for the top five novels everyone should read.
“But my top five would be The Brothers Karamazov, Soldier of the Great War. Brothers Karamazov by Dostoevsky. Soldier of the Great War by Mark Halperin, In the First Circle by Alexander Solzhenitsyn.”
“But my top five would be The Brothers Karamazov, Soldier of the Great War. Brothers Karamazov by Dostoevsky. Soldier of the Great War by Mark Halperin, In the First Circle by Alexander Solzhenitsyn.”
Why: Ranked as one of Russ Roberts's top favorite novels.
“But my top five would be The Brothers Karamazov, Soldier of the Great War. Brothers Karamazov by Dostoevsky. Soldier of the Great War by Mark Halperin, In the First Circle by Alexander Solzhenitsyn.”
“Leo Damrosch, Adventurer, The Life and Times of Casanova, which is a book about 18th century Venice, the Enlightenment, Casanova himself. And it's wonderful. I'm a big fan of Damrosch.”
Why: It is a wonderful book about 18th-century Venice, the Enlightenment, and Casanova, and all of Damrosch's books are very good.
“I don't know how to pronounce his name, but called I Am the Cheese. It's one of the scariest books I've ever read. It's written for teenagers. It's the creepiest thing I've ever read. It's a phenomenal book.”
Why: It is a phenomenal, creepy, and scary book written for teenagers.
“But Alexander Kotov, How to Think Like a Grandmaster, which is still a wonderful book for learning how to do almost anything. So it encapsulated a lot of the wisdom of the Soviet school of chess…”
Why: It is a fantastic book even for non-chess players because it teaches how to improve at almost anything through exercises with real feedback.
“I think my first favorite book was by Leonard Kessler, who just died. And it was something like Mr. Pines Paints a House. And it's a kid's book. But that was my favorite when I was three.”
Why: It was his first favorite children's book when he was three years old.
“because it what's fun is some of those books i mean a good example would be um you know um jane air jane air is incredibly entertaining. One of my kids had to read it and I hadn't read it since I was 15.”
Why: It is incredibly entertaining and the writing is so good.
“But you remind me that when I was 17 and read it for the first time, I was just overwhelmed. I couldn't – I think I read Anthem first, a very, very short novella, and it just set me on fire.”
Why: It is a very short novella with powerful storytelling that set him on fire when he read it at 17.
“But I think Atlas Shrugged in particular, it was highly prophetic, and it's become underrated as sociology. like her cocktail party scenes, her account of what we now call the woke.”
Why: While too long and one-sided overall, its cocktail party scenes and sociological critique of conformity are highly prophetic and golden.
“Yeah, the first 100 pages is just such a tour de force of storytelling. Forget the philosophy and the economics. It's just hard to put down. It's a really good book, but it is 1,200 pages.”
“So I made a list of books that I thought changed me. I thought Anarchy, State, and Utopia by Robert Nozick, which I have not gone back to, but it had a huge impact on me.”
“Fooled by Randomness, which was like Vitality was the beginning of my obsession with being deceived by numbers and the challenge of thinking about uncertainty, which I don't think I'll ever lose that fascination.”
Why: It sparked his enduring fascination with uncertainty and how people are deceived by numbers.
“So it would be – his first book I think you've heard of. It's called African Genesis. And the theme of it was very simple. It was that we came out of Africa, humanity, not out of the Tigris-Euphrates area.”
Why: Part of a trilogy by Ardrey that had a huge impact on Roberts when he was younger.
“And then the third book he wrote, it was called The Social Contract, which I'd love to go back and read. When I finished that book, it was 1976. I was 22 years old, and I remember being so overwhelmed by how that book opened my brain.”
Why: It overwhelmed him, opened his brain, and made him realize what a book could do.
“My dad gave me, I was about that age, my dad gave me a book called The Passover Plot, which was this fantastic attempt to explain the facts of Jesus's life as a conspiracy.”
Why: He describes it as a fantastic, fabulous attempt to explain the facts of Jesus's life as a conspiracy.
“I think iRobot, Mike O'Down, is the most influential book of the 20th century, not counting something like Mein Kampf, which is a very different direction.”
Why: It is arguably the most influential book of the 20th century, examining AI governance through laws that double as a satiric commentary on religious law.
“start with iRobot I guess so yeah try Olaf Stapleton last and first men from the 30s he was a neo-Hegelian philosopher who sketched out how he thought the world was going to evolve…”
Why: Recommended as a foundational science fiction work by a neo-Hegelian philosopher sketching out the future evolution of the world.
“Sound and the Fury, the most famous one, is very, very, very hard to read if you just pick it up and try to read it because you don't know what's going on. Once you get the hang of it, it's very good.”
Why: It is very hard to read if you just pick it up cold, but once you get the hang of it, it is very good.
“And by the way, my other confession, I've never read Ulysses by James Joyce or Finnegan's Wake. Have you read either one? Ulysses has to be in my top five if I can put in seven.”
Why: It is easy, fun, in Cowen's top tier of novels, and intersects with Judaism, cosmopolitanism, the Irish, and Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments.
“how about montana the essays do you read them yes uh i have a very high opinion of them i i've gone back to them they just seem a little slow for me right now they are but i love they haven't gone down in my eyes i think they're pretty amazing…”
Why: They are amazing, humane in a deep way, and still feel modern and ahead of their time.
“I remember when I read Brian Kaplan, my former colleague, your current colleague, his book, The Myth of the Rational Voter. There's an interesting idea on every page.”
Why: Unlike most nonfiction books, it has an interesting idea on every single page.
“So have you read some by David Eagleman? I don't think so. S-U-M? No. Can I give you a copy? You can. I'll read it too. Okay. It's real short. It's a magical book. It's phenomenal.”
Speakers who argue against the book or name its limits.
“Okay, so Proust is unbearable and unreadable. Terrible book. I read volume, I read En Recherche des Tons Perdues, In Search of Lost Time, I think is the way it goes.”
Why: Roberts found the first volume, Swann's Way, unbearable and unreadable.
“which is volume one of, no, Swan's Way, sorry, Swan's Way, which is the first volume of In Search of Lost Time. I got through it because in those days when I was younger, I would always finish a book I started…”
Why: He disliked it and only finished it because he hadn't yet learned to abandon books he wasn't enjoying.
“I prefer Tolstoy's short fiction and maybe it's strange to call Anna Karenina predictable at this point in time we all know the book, of course it's predictable but in some way it's less striking and novel to me…”
“And he is now losing to Macron, but he wrote a book available only to me in Spanish, though he wrote it in French. It's called El Primer Sexo, like the first sex.”
Why: It is mostly long and rambling so he might quit it, though it is good Spanish practice and noteworthy given Zemmour's political candidacy.
“Game of Thrones, either on TV or in the books. I can see the appeal. I'm just not sure at the end of it all what I'll have. And I stop reading, stop watching.”
Why: While he sees the appeal, it feels too slow and he is unsure what value he will have at the end of it.
“I don't think you can solve it. I think you have to read it as a very long poem. As that, for me, it comes across as tedious, but I suspect it's very good along some dimension I don't care about much.”
Why: It comes across as tedious even when read as a long poem.
“Lolita is hard to read. When you read it from a current vantage point, you see just how brutal a story it is. It's horrible. And it's almost unbearable.”
Why: From a current vantage point, the story is so brutal and horrible that it is almost unbearable to read.
“But it's striking to me, the book I just finished writing called Talent with Daniel Grouse, my co-author. I read remarkably few books to write that book.”
“The earlier parts of my life, I spend a much higher percentage of my reading, reading the kinds of books that would be in the back section of Harold Bloom's The Western Canon.”
“And there's this book by Thomas Bernhardt called The Voice Imitator. Der Stimmen imitator, which is short stories that are only a paragraph long, and they're in German.”
“My mother ended up as a reader. She would read books like Jonathan Livingston Seagull, like popular but smart, maybe vaguely spiritual books, smarter self-help books, books on psychology.”
“Now, I want to talk about that in a sec, but I got to mention first, have you read Worlds in Collision by Emmanuel Velikovsky? As a kid, I did. I was like, oh, my goodness.”
“I think iRobot, Mike O'Down, is the most influential book of the 20th century, not counting something like Mein Kampf, which is a very different direction.”