“And they stood the test of time. In fact, in 1970, he won the Nobel Prize in Literature for these novels. And we know them as One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich.”
One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich on EconTalk
Recommended in this episode
Books a speaker recommends that someone else wrote.
“And they stood the test of time. In fact, in 1970, he won the Nobel Prize in Literature for these novels. And we know them as One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich.”
Why: It is an important novel about the Soviet labor camps from firsthand experience that has stood the test of time.
“and the life experience of 226 other political prisoners whom he interviewed and whose stories are related in that magnificent three-volume Gulag Archipelago, the first volume, as I said, of which appeared in 1973. This is a singular achievement.”
Why: A magnificent, well-documented, and readable three-volume page-turner that proved the Soviet regime was rotten from its roots.
“And for years, over a decade, certainly in the 80s and a lot of the 90s, I would recommend that they read The Gulag Archipelago just out of tribute to his courage in writing that book.”
“I felt like morally he deserved for people to read that book. I also would recommend Ann Applebaum's book, The Gulag, which is a very nice shorter version of the history.”
Why: It provides a very nice, shorter version of the history of the Soviet Gulag.
“I encourage listeners to go back to the – if you haven't heard it, the episode we did with Yoram Hozoni in his book The Virtue of Nationalism, which is kind of shocking.”
Why: Challenges the easy Western assumption that liberal democracy and capitalism will inevitably sweep the world.
“But I still could enjoy in the first circle, just like I enjoy the Brothers Karamazov. It's a magnificent book. I don't think Dostoevsky was so friendly to Jews, but it's not really the – I still can learn a lot from him.”
Why: It is a magnificent book that one can enjoy and learn a lot from despite the author's prejudices.
“And my view is I don't particularly think he is an anti-Semite. I'm glad to hear you agree. But I still could enjoy in the first circle, just like I enjoy the Brothers Karamazov. It's a magnificent book.”
Speakers who argue against the book or name its limits.
“and so in some ways the In the First Circle returns to that 1945 episode. However, it isn't integral to the novel and it isn't a successful portrait, however understandable it is psychologically.”
Why: While the novel as a whole stood the test of time, its portrait of Stalin is psychological revenge rather than a successful characterization.
The author, or a host talking with the author, discusses the book. Not counted as a recommendation.
“He is also a senior fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution. Among many books, he is the author of a massive award-winning biography of Joseph Stalin.”
Why: It is a massive, award-winning biography of Joseph Stalin.
“You're writing a biography of Stalin that you've issued. You've published the first two volumes. Is that correct? Two? Yes. To date? And they come to 2,000 pages, although I'm sure that includes a lot of footnotes and references.”
Passing References
Named without an opinion attached.
“And so this achievement of Solzhenitsyn, 1,800 pages, much longer than War and Peace, longer than Homer's Iliad and Odyssey combined, and yet readable, a page-turner in many ways.”
“And so this achievement of Solzhenitsyn, 1,800 pages, much longer than War and Peace, longer than Homer's Iliad and Odyssey combined, and yet readable, a page-turner in many ways.”
“And so this achievement of Solzhenitsyn, 1,800 pages, much longer than War and Peace, longer than Homer's Iliad and Odyssey combined, and yet readable, a page-turner in many ways.”
“So in fact, One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich was approved by Khrushchev for publication in the Soviet Union. And it's a story about one of the labor camps loosely based on Solzhenitsyn's firsthand experience.”
“Moreover, we now have the secret documents, KGB documents and Politburo documents about Solzhenitsyn, which were published a number of years ago as the Solzhenitsyn Files, which shows exactly as you suggested that the regime didn't know how to handle him.”