โHer book was called In Defense of Troublemakers. And we had a conversation along these lines.โ
Russ Roberts, Host on EconTalkMegan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap

Charlan Nemeth ยท 2018
A social psychology book arguing that dissent and contrarian perspectives improve group decision-making and creativity.
Russ Roberts appreciates its reminder that group consensus can easily foster false confidence and lead decisions astray.
Affiliate links: we may earn a commission, at no cost to you.
Dissenters and contrarians prevent erroneous group consensus by challenging collective certainty and standing up against groupthink.
Leaders dealing with deep uncertainty who need to balance strong conviction with the humility to question their own conclusions.
Skip if you already understand how to manage organizational consensus and group decision-making.
Summarized from what was said in 3 conversations; the quotes are below.
Start here
โHer book was called In Defense of Troublemakers. And we had a conversation along these lines.โ
Russ Roberts on EconTalk
A speaker recommends a book written by someone else.
โHer book was called In Defense of Troublemakers. And we had a conversation along these lines.โ
Russ Roberts, Host on EconTalkMegan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
โI went on to talk about a quote from her book, group decisions are often in error, never in doubt. I said I think that's a great line, and when we leave a meeting, have a made decision, we're all high. We did a great job. We did the right thing. We came to the right conclusion. Being aware of the possibility that you're wrong is a great thing to be reminded of. And I said, I think that's one of the things your book does.โ
Why: Reminds readers of the possibility of being wrong even when group consensus feels certain.
Russ Roberts, Host on EconTalkDavid Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility
The author, or a host talking with the author, discusses the book. Not counted as an endorsement.
โHer latest book is In Defense of Troublemakers, The Power of Dissent in Life and Business, which is our topic for today.โ
Russ Roberts, Host on EconTalkCharlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers
More from this conversation
โThis book is about decision-making, in particular how our awareness of what others say and believe, how those others affect our own decisions.โ
Charlan Nemeth, Guest
Named without an opinion attached.
โBut her book is called In Defense of Troublemakers, and in a way you can think about Churchill as a troublemaker.โ
Why: Explores the importance of dissenters who stand up against groupthink and reminds readers that group decisions are often in error.
Russ Roberts, Host on EconTalkDavid Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility
Other books cited in the same episodes.

On Being Certain
Robert Burton
Discussed together in: David Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility (EconTalk)
The Invisible Heart
Russ Roberts
Discussed together in: Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers (EconTalk)
In the First Circle
Aleksandr I. Solzhenitsyn
Discussed together in: Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers (EconTalk)
The Years of Lyndon Johnson (Volumes 1-3)
Robert A. Caro
Discussed together in: David Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility (EconTalk)

Skin in the Game
Nassim Nicholas Taleb
Discussed together in: David Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility (EconTalk)

Churchill: Walking with Destiny
Andrew Roberts
Discussed together in: David Deppner on Leadership, Confidence, and Humility (EconTalk)

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
Ken Kesey
Discussed together in: Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap (EconTalk)

Out of Africa
Isak Dinesen
Discussed together in: Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap (EconTalk)
Add it to your website or newsletter. It links back here, where readers can hear each recommendation at its timestamp.
<a href="https://podcited.com/books/in-defense-of-troublemakers-nemeth?utm_source=badge"><img src="https://podcited.com/badge/in-defense-of-troublemakers-nemeth.svg" alt="Recommended on EconTalk ยท PodCited" width="265" height="28"></a>